Mystikol

Mystikol®

A totally new kind of eyeliner and highlighter that creates definition around the eye for a soft, smoky eye effect. 

The Look saturated The Feel creamy

A creamy formula that won’t fade, crease or smear. Hypoallergenic and dermatologist-tested, Mystikol is safe for even the most sensitive eyes.

  • Amethyst:  royal purple with a shimmery lilac highlighter
  • Aquamarine:  sea green with shimmery silver highlighter
  • Citrine:  metallic bronze and a buttery beige highlighter
  • Dark Topaz:  chocolate brown with a shimmery gold highlighter
  • Lapis Lazuli:  deep blue with a creamy sandy beige highlighter
  • Malachite:  mossy green with a creamy nude highlighter
  • Onyx:  jet black with a creamy ivory highlighter
  • Smoky Quartz:  smoky grey with a pearl peach highlighter

Cyclopentasiloxane, Mica, Cetearyl Ethylhexanoate, Cera Alba (Beeswax), Copernicia Cerifera Cera, Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Tocopherol. [+/- (May Contain) Iron Oxides (Ci 77489, Ci 77491, Ci 77492, Ci 77499), Ultramarines (Ci 77007), Manganese Violet (Ci 77742), Chromium Oxide Greens (Ci 77288)]

  • Apply the rich eyeliner and highlighter directly to the eye with the sponge applicator. Blend with finger, sponge tip or brush if desired.
  • The highlighter can be applied along the brow bone, cheek bone or to the inner corner of your eyes.
  • Can be applied as an eye shadow to entire eye area.
  • Vary the intensity for a neat daytime look or for all-out smoky eyes.
  • Mystikol®
    None of these shades contain wheat
  • Mystikol Onyx
    Vegans will want to avoid this shade (This product contains beeswax).
  • Mystikol Dark Topaz
    Vegans will want to avoid this shade (This product contains beeswax).
  • Mystikol Amethyst
    Vegans will want to avoid this shade (This product contains beeswax).
  • Mystikol Malachite
    Vegans will want to avoid this shade (This product contains beeswax).
  • Mystikol Lapis Lazuli
    Vegans will want to avoid this shade (This product contains beeswax).
  • Mystikol Aquamarine
    Vegans will want to avoid this shade (This product contains beeswax).
  • Mystikol Citrine
    Vegans will want to avoid this shade (This product contains beeswax).
  • Mystikol Smoky Quartz
    Vegans will want to avoid this shade (This product contains beeswax).

jane iredale is certified cruelty-free by the Coalition for Consumer Information on Cosmetics’ (CCIC) Leaping Bunny Program, the leading internationally respected animal protection group for cruelty-free certification. Find out more on our cruelty-free page.

jane iredale products are also certified cruelty-free by PETA. To find out more about what this means, please visit our page on their site.

Options

  • Onyx Onyx
  • Dark Topaz Dark Topaz
  • Amethyst Amethyst
  • Malachite Malachite
  • Lapis Lazuli Lapis Lazuli
  • Aquamarine Aquamarine
  • Citrine Citrine
  • Smoky Quartz Smoky Quartz

Reviews

Average Rating 3.8 (76 Reviews)
3.8158/5

Love the color...need new applicator product

5/5
I was recently introduced to JI cosmetics by my aesthetician. I am just finishing up my initial purchase of JI products (I bought the full line in everything). The Mystikol Smoky Quartz was my favorite color of the two (also purchased the dark green color) I purchased. However, both have broken caps at the threads, and the color in the caps which broke are dried out. I would really like to repurchase, but not if the product is flawed. It appears that you have numerous complaints about this applicator. Is there a plan to maybe come up with a better applicator???

Our Response

Welcome to jane iredale and we’re glad you love Mystikols! We’re sorry your caps broke and these can be fragile. It’s important to take extra care when putting the caps back on. We try our hardest to make improvements based on feedback, so thank you for sharing your experience. We'd love to send you replacements so you can enjoy your Mystikols again. If you're interested, please contact our Personal Shoppers at 877-869-9420 or personalshoppers@janeiredale.com.

Flawed Design

2/5
I'm a huge fan of JI, and have been using these products for years. This is the first one I'm not flipped over. I actually really like the product but the design & structure of the product must be flawed? Mine broke quickly after just a few uses. I read other reviews of so many breaking and so I made a point to be very careful, but it still broke. The colors are subtle, I went for the grey/pink. The grey is very light, not as dark as I'd hoped for. It's difficult to acquire the smokey look. The pink highlighter is pretty, but the colored cap broke and doesn't stay on, which makes it difficult to use and keep track of

Love this stuff!!

5/5
I have had the same Mystikol eyeliner pencil for about 1 year, and it has been fabulous. It goes on smoothly, with no clumping or creasing, whatsoever! I do have to take the end of my long eyeshadow brush and loosen the makeup that is in the cap, but after that, it's good for quite awhile. I love the effect on my eyes, and I use this on an almost daily basis. I would recommend this product to anyone!!

Super!

5/5
I really like these eyeliners; the effect in my eyes is amazing! I can use these as eyeliner or as an eyeshadow creating a dramatic effect! Just gorgeous!! :)

Hard to use

2/5
I love the color but it doesn't seem to last at all. I followed the directions of pumping it in the cap but when i use it for under my eyes and go back and forth very little comes out. I just opened the one I have so I'm not sure why this is happening.

Our Response

We’re sorry your Mystikol isn’t working properly and it should last for over 200 applications! We’d like to send a replacement and if you’re interested, please contact our Personal Shoppers at 877-869-9420 or personalshoppers@janeiredale.com

What a cool product

5/5
I received the Mystikol in Citrine. I am only used to traditional eyeliners and was not sure how I would do with this product. What a cool eyeliner. The metallic bronze eyeliner really makes the eyes pop without being over the top. Easy to apply...big plus for me. The highlighter is very versatile. I definitely plan on trying some new colors. Love it!

Almost Perfect

4/5
I am an avid Jane Iredale user and love all of the products I have used. I recently purchased Mystikol and loved it. I say loved only because less than one week later there was very little product left. I paid so much money for this product and I am disappointed. I would love to keep using this product. Keep your receipt so you can return exchange for another if the same thing happens to you. I wish I had.

Our Response

Thank you so much for your loyalty (and the love!). Your Mystikol should last you much longer than one week and we’re so sorry the one you have stopped working. It sounds like there may be something wrong with the one you received, but first, may we ask if you’ve pumped the applicator into the cap? Since the eyeliner is stored in the cap, it’s necessary to pump to reload the applicator. If you’ve done this and you’re still having trouble, we’d like to replace your Mystikol so you can continue enjoying it! If you’re in need of an exchange, please contact our Personal Shoppers at 877-869-9420 or personalshoppers@janeiredale.com.

Great for Waterline

5/5
I don't use the color much, but I use the lighter highliter in the lower waterline all the time. It floats on without any tugging, and stays put for hours.

Eyeliner was dry, no color

1/5
What happened to this product? I've used Mystikol for years, and loved the soft natural look it gave my eyes. But the last 3 pencils I purchased were dry, releasing no color at all unless I pressed hard on my eyelid (and then the color was only faint). I'm giving up on these pencils. The product is much, much too expensive to keep buying when I get no results.

Our Response

We're sorry you've noticed a change! Sometimes it's necessary to load the applicator with product by gently pumping it into the cap. If you find your Mystikols are still dry after pumping, then something must be wrong and our Personal Shoppers will be happy to help you with a replacement. You can reach them at 877-869-9420 or personalshoppers@janeiredale.com. We hope you'll give the Mystikols another chance!

Love This Liner!!!

5/5
It's hard to reconcile the negative comments with the liner I received. I chose the Topaz and it is so natural looking, easy to apply, not clumpy at all and never smears or streaks. It just gives a lovely smoky effect and if yo want a deeper tone you can just apply a second coat. I have very sensitive eyes and a lot of allergies and this gives me no problems at all. I'm going to order a different shade. i love this product!

Broken

1/5
I bought this in dark topaz, I used it twice and the threaded part of the applicator broke off and is stuck in the cap so it doesn't stay closed. The product is in the cap but doesn't seem to collect on the applicator when it is pumped, then clumps at the bottom of the applicator. Disappointed because I love Jane products.

Our Response

Oh no! We're sorry about the broken cap, that shouldn't have happened. We'd love to send you a replacement so you can enjoy your Mystikol again. If you're interested, please contact our Personal Shoppers at 877-869-9420 or personalshoppers@janeiredale.com.

great product!

5/5
This is the best product! I have used and tried everything out there.I live in eyeliner, even sleep in it! I feel naked without it...and this is so natural and easy to put on. I use the dark topaz and my daughter uses the purple. It stays on all day. I live in Texas and sweat to death and it stays on. I sometimes have to touch up late in the day. I have also ordered the pencil to try.

Need tips

4/5
I have the onyx and I love the color and the idea behind the design but I can't figure out how to make it work. The first two times I used it it was great. Now I can't get the applicator to hold enough color to line my eyes. I don't do a smoky eye, just a regular line. I can't figure out what I'm doing wrong. If someone could give me some tips I'd appreciate it because I'd love to try two of the other colors if I can make it work. Thanks

Our Response

We’re happy to help you! It sounds like you need to load the applicator with more product and to do this you simply pump the cap and the applicator. To see a demonstration, feel free to watch the application video on the video tab next to the product on our website!

Love these

5/5
I have reviewed these before but wanted to say that they have stood the test of time and i still love them. I use these when I'm on the go and want to be put together. Just swipe them on and they are on tell I wash them off. They are great for making smoky eyes As well. I have it in auqamarine, smokey quartz, citrine, and malachite. Can't say enough good things about them. I will collect all of these.

Amazing

5/5
I tried this in the black and didn't care for it at all. Then I tried the brown and FELL IN LOVE. You have to learn to use the angled applicator to get the size line you want, but this stuff is amazing. I swear if you ever take it away I don't know what I will do.

Mystikol

2/5
I have been happily using a range of Jane Iredale products for the past two years. A bit tired of eye pencils and purepressed eyeshadows (the particles of which tend to fall under the lower eyelids and give a tired and messy look), for summer, I decided to go for the Mystikol which I found at my local pharmacy in Istanbul. I bought both Amethyst and Aquamarine colors. I was a bit dismayed that the Amethyst was very dark, almost a brownish grey when applied. I loved the color of Aquamarine. My biggest dissapointment though was that the caps of both Mystikols cracked in the first week, although I was handling them quite gently, as I had read the reviews that they broke easily. My local pharmacy could not help me with an exchange. I think the designs or cap materials of Mystikols should be changed to prevent cracks from happening which seems to be quite prevalent, rather than isolated cases.

Our Response

We're glad to hear you're enjoying jane iredale and that you’re experimenting with new products! Based on shopper feedback, like yours, we’re happy to let you know that we’ve made changes and have improved our Mystikols’ componentry. Since you’re located in Istanbul, we will inquire with our distributer about replacements for your broken Mystikols, since we want you to be happy again! You can also contact them directly at 0090 216 469 or d.tanik@rosspharma.com.tr.

Aquamarine

5/5
I am very happy with this product it goes on great and stays on all day. It looks great with my green eyes.

Great Eyeliner & Shadow

5/5
Like some people, I was a little skeptical about Mytsicol. I love the liquid eyeliner and am a devoted fan. I originally purchased Aquamarine and Malachite as eye shadows - mainly for travel. They are so easy to throw in a travel bag and go. Since then, I have used these 2 colors to complement one another - lid and crease - and now use them as eyeliners. I have not experienced any issues with clumping and find these color sticks great! My next choice will be citrine because I love the Copper Liquid Eyeliner. I am a devoted fan!

Mystikol

2/5
I really loved the color and easy application of this product. It was called hypoallergenic in the description, but caused my eyes to be red and irritated. Wish that I could use it!

Our Response

We're sorry to hear of your sensitivity! Our products are hypoallergenic and we try our very hardest to eliminate all known sensitizers. Our Personal Shoppers will be happy to help you with a return or exchange and you can contact them at 877-869-9420 or personalshoppers@janeiredale.com.

Lovely amethyst, smooth but experiment

5/5
I bought amethyst. Normally I wear black. For reference I have tan medium dark skin (I'm south Asian and grew up wearing home made kajal). The amethyst color is beautiful. My eyes look a shade lighter shade of brown than dark brown when I wear it. The highlighter under the brow and inner corner of eyes work well and gives a subtle 'alive' look. The tip of eyeliner is not super smooth, but good enough. It works very well on the upper lid- something I have not been able to do well with other eyeliners. Hesitate to get the black given other reviews, but am tempted too give JIs quality.

love color..hate applicator

1/5
Love the color but the pencil cap on the highlighter broke again! Called the personal shopper and they replaced it the first time. The replacement worked for a week at most then the end broke again. Very disappointed with the applicator. Is anyone else having this problem?

Our Response

We understand your disappointment and are sorry! Our Mystikol caps can be fragile and require a gentle touch when tightening them. We’d like to help you again and will contact you privately to arrange a replacement.

wish was packaged differently

3/5
I bought this in the kit, I had been wanting to try it and loved the colors in it on my skin tone however the top broke for the peach highlighter the second day I had it, so upsetting. I still love the peach highlighter though I am curious as to what would be the closest product with the same color range and effect?

Our Response

Oh no, we’re sorry the cap broke! If you’d like a peach highlighter, try Petal Lid Primer or Hush Eye Shadow.

Love!

5/5
It took a little experimenting to get used to applying (as I am used to a regular pencil-style eyeliner), but now I love them! They go on smooth and it's easy to achieve a soft, smoky look. Best of all, they don't irritate my eyes even when wearing contact lenses (something I can't say for any other makeup brand I've tried!). I've even used the lighter highlighting end as eyeshadow. I currently have the Dark Topaz and Smoky Quartz shades, and both are flattering with my fair skin, dark hair and blue eyes. I look forward to trying more shades!

Love Mystikol except for Onyx

4/5
I have a number of these liners and love them all with the exception of Onyx. I too find it very messy. The other colors go on very smoothly and last but after just an hour I find Onyx is all over and I don't rub my eyes. Citrine, Quartz and Amethyst are beautiful.

Great Product...not so good packaging

3/5
I absolutely love the concept of the packaging and the product....however it broke. I was introduced to this product via the Mesmerizing Grab&Go Kit and love it. Its extremely easy to apply makeup. I don't wear makeup all the time, went to use and the end was broke so I was let down!

Almost Perfect

4/5
I bought the purple color in this and loved it so much that I also purchased the brown color. It goes on so smooth and perfect. The only problem is that after having it for about a week, the light colored end of my purple liner broke and now the cap will not screw on leaving that end messy and useless. I can still use the dark end that is the most important. Other than the one broken end, I love this product.

Our Response

We’re glad you’re enjoying your Mystikol, and we’re so sorry to hear about your broken cap! We’ll message you privately to arrange an exchange so you can enjoy both the eyeliner and highlighter ends of your Mystikol.

Robin

5/5
Used this liner tonight....will NEVER use it again ......... Looked like a very scary CLOWN!!!! IT looked awful!!! Will never use this again.... it was embarrassing !!!!

Our Response

We are so sorry that you are not happy with our Mystikol. We are happy to arrange an exchange for you, Please e-mail our Personal Shoppers at personalshoppers@janeiredale.com or call 877-869-9420.

surprised

5/5
I have been using Jane Iredale base powder for years and love it. It is great quality and worth the cost. I finally decided to splurge on the Mystikol eyeliner because the colors looked so vibrant and the description made it seem like a breeze to apply. I use an Aveda eyeliner pencil, but I was looking for something that would stick a little better and make my eyes pop. I was so disappointed when I put the Amethyst Mystikol liner on. It blobbed, didn't go on smooth and dropped in clumps onto my face. Ugh, wow, surprising. I was thinking I was buying something that was going to be great quality. I might be a little less likely to try other products.

Our Response

We are so sorry that your Mystikol was clumping on you. It should glide on smoothly, but it sounds like the applicator is delivering too much product. It shouldn't do that, so we would be happy to exchange it for you. In the meantime you might try rolling the applicator on a towel or tissue to remove excess product before application. Please contact a Personal Shopper at personalshoppers@janeiredale.com or 1-866-869-9420.

Terrible packing, waste of money

1/5
While I love most Jane Iredale products, this one was a complete waste of money. The design is awful. The first day the spring broke on the grey side and so it wouldn't seal shut and dried out, and a few days later I dropped the tube and the spring on the pink side broke. Needless to say, it wound up in the trash. Pretty colors, terrible packing.

mystikol

5/5
Wanted to love this product but the caps keep breaking and the liner gets thick and dryed out. The applicator does not really work well. I had to use another brush or q-tip to apply the liner. Very disappointed and I've never been unhappy with a Jane Iredale product before.

Love it

5/5
I bought the dark topaz and love this product. In the summertime I do have to be a bit careful here in the hot texas weather or I might end up looking like a racoon but I actually use this product to fill in and blend a liquid liner I apply. During the winter this product works fine for me alone. I love that it has the lighter color on the under end that I use under my brow and at the points of my eyes for some shimmer. Lovely product especially when you learn to apply it correctly. A little goes a long way.

Love Citrine

5/5
I love the citrine shade. It is perfect for my brown eyes and gives just the right amount of shimmer.

Wonderful!!!

5/5
Wonderfully easy to apply, looks FANTASTIC and stays all day. Must be SMUDGED for the darker color, not meant to be a hard thin line. Highlighter looks GREAT though it doesn't seem to last very long. Looks totally amazing and stays put till you take it off. Top notch!!

**ADDICTED**

5/5
One more thing, my eyes used to get very red throughout the day. Ever since I switched to this liner and the JI Longest Lash, I no longer get red eyes. A fantastic addition to the pretty makeup. THANK YOU! Also, please do not discontinue citrine. Contact me if that is planned so I can hoard that as well!

**ADDICTED**

5/5
This eyeliner is AMAZING. I have purchased all 7 colors and use it every day. I get TONS of compliments and many of my girlfriends have gone out to buy it. I do use a base on my eyelid, and the liner stays all day without dropping any powder onto my face. The colors are insanely pretty but my favorite is the Aquamarine. I hear it is a summer color only, but PLEASE do not discontinue it. If you plan to, please email me first so I can hoard it! If you like a really thin line, this product may not be for you... but you can control the width of the product. AMAZING AMAZING AMAZING. An investment well worth it. Also, although it doesn't look like you get much product.. this does last a long time!

Run, don't walk!

5/5
Get this. Just do it. You'll understand :)

Mystikol

2/5
I bought the aquamarine/icy pink mystikol eyeliner, and I have found that it is better for an eyeshadow. I use the pale pink for highlighter/eyeshadow, but I hardly ever use the aquamarine because the line comes out to thick and the color is too pale for eyeliner. It's better for a smudged/night out look, but not for everyday. Also, the case broke and getting the eyeliner out is really tricky.

Thick and Messy

1/5
I have found my mystikol (onyx) to be too hard to use - I like a 1960's 'Brigitte Bardot look', - quite a thick line but the mystikol tip went on too thick to control. Unfortunately It also bled everywhere and I had black rings under my eyes. It was expensive and I can't use it, however I have read some other customers comments regarding their mystikol having a fine tip applicator - Maybe theirs was a different batch?? Have you changed the tip of the applicator?

my new favorite!

5/5
Mystikol is a great find and I am so glad I tried this product. I bought the dark topaz and it is a rich brown and has great pigment. It glides on like silk and does did not irritate my eyes. Was able to draw a thin line as well as a more intense line for a smokier effect. The highlighter end is a lovely color but too much product comes out of the cap and clumps on the applicator to the point it reaches the threading on the cap, it isn't a huge issue with respect to using product, just a small inconvenience to clean. Worth a try!!!

So cool!

4/5
This is an innovative and interesting product, it's fun to use and it's a great value bc it lasts FOREVER. The pigmentation of the liner is incredibly vibrant. I have Lapis Lazuli, which is a deep sapphire color. The highlighter is great for inner eye corner. My only complaint is that this SMUDGES! I apply it with a flat liner brush, I've tried it with and without an eye primer, I've set it with setting powder (this helped the most), but nothing fully keeps it from ending up in a mirrored ring on my eyelid and a little below my eyes. I wish it didn't make me look so sick and tired by the end of the day. I will probably still buy the Emerald color and the citrine and survive the smudging, but any advice would be welcome!

Our Response

It sounds like you’re applying the product correctly but we do have a suggestion for you! Sometimes eye creams can be the culprit to smudging eye liner. You may want to try applying your eye cream at night so it has plenty of time to absorb into your skin completely.

Very Happy

5/5
This is what I have been looking for! I do not want a defined 'line' but the ability to have a smokey line. I can control whether it is a thinner or thicker line with the applicator. I am very pleased. I am finding no clumping or having to wipe excess off; and I don't wear eye colors super darkly. Thanks for the product!

Mystikol - Dark Topaz, Citrine, Amethyst, Malachite

5/5
This is pretty clever stuff! Yes, the color is in the cap and it may look like a small amount...yes there is a learning curve...but this product is amazing. Watch the video of the application process and you will see how easy it is to use. Make sure you have a smudging brush and/or tapered eyeliner brush and you can not go wrong. Just remember you have to be light handed not heavy handed. I am a green eyed brunette with cool undertones to my skin so the colors I chose work best with my eye color. Tons of compliments with all colors!

Love it!

5/5
The best eyeliner ever. The intensity of a liquid with the softness of a pencil and the blendability of a powder. Takes a little practice to apply but if you use it over foundation it never smudges or smears.

Awesome

5/5
I love this eyeliner! It goes on great and last long without smudging.

Finally No Pulling

5/5
Love this eyeliner - Is a little learning curve but WOW no tugging or pulling on sensitive skin. Able to do both fine line or "smudge" depending on my mood. Also, removes easily with water so again no harsh chemical to remove.

Well....

4/5
I wanted to love this. The colors are fantastic, vibrant and smooth. Application is easy. I have no complaints whatsoever about the highlighting end. But this SMEARS. Like, wow. I use an eye base underneath and halfway through the day the line is mirrored on my upper eyelid. Not a good look. I'll use this till I run out but I'm not repurchasing. A waterproof version or improved formula would be awesome!

Our Response

May we ask if you’re currently applying Mystikol with a brush? If not, try applying the Mystikol with an eye liner brush. When loading the brush with product, be sure to take the product off the sponge tip applicator, not from the cap. The Mystikols are highly pigmented, so only a very small amount is needed. Using the brush will allow you to control the amount of product used, and can help get a tight line. Setting the Mystikol with a powder eye shadow or applying it over the shadow or a light application of foundation will also help increase the length of wear. Finally, try a light spray of Hydration Spray after application, and this may help set the liner.

Has its advantages

3/5
The applicator tip is too wide or I just have a difficult time applying. I usually end up looking like a raccoon. I have found if I use an eyeliner brush to apply I can control the line thickness. The biggest plus of this eyeliner is that it literally stays on until you intentionally take it off.

Smooth pretty colours

4/5
I have the onyx, amethyst, lapis lazuli, aquamarine and citrine. All of the colours applied beautifully, smooth and precise, except onyx. Onyx was a thick and clumpy and harder to apply, however, after wiping it on the inside of the cap it came out better. I wonder why onyx is a different consistency to the other colours? All colours lasted all day with a primer, but didn't last very long without one. You also have to be careful when applying, I noticed small flakes during the day if you didn't apply it smoothly. All of the highlighters were quite similar so I suggest they put a different eyeliner colour on the ends, perhaps pink or a terracotta.

Caps kept breaking !

1/5
I bought this in 3 different colors - which means I had a large investment and on all three of them the caps cracked and kept falling off. Plus it they didnt last long - they seemed to dry out really fast. I loved the colors but, the dried up pretty quick. I won't buy this product again.

Our Response

We’re so sorry to hear you’re having trouble with the caps, and it sounds like this may be causing the product to dry up. When putting the caps on the Mystikols, it’s important to be gentle and to not over tighten the cap, which can then cause the cap to crack or no longer fasten to the applicator.

Mystikol Product Great, Packaging Bad

3/5
i LOVE the eyeliner. it's the only one i use because it doesn't feel heavy and doesn't itch. BUT - not sure how much you get for the price. i noticed after a few weeks the applicator, which retracts, wasn't fully grabbing the product which seems stuffed high up into the cap. at the beginning i got a decent amount of product and a great solid eye line. now, i press in over and over and the applicator is going as far as it can and the product is stuffed too far in... bummer...

Our Response

Hi there, We’re sorry to hear you’re having trouble, and this should not happen. We’ve personally tested Mystikols and gave up at 200 applications, which was well before the liner ran out! It seems that there may be something wrong with the one you received, and we’d be happy to replace it. When you have a moment, please contact a Personal Shopper who will assist you with your replacement. You can reach them at 877-869-9420 or personalshoppers@janeiredale.com.

Play with it...

5/5
I tried the black and white one at first and thought it was much too gloppy and smudgy. Then I tried a lighter color and it was all the difference in the world. It goes on smoothly, stays on forever and is easy. I would say that if you haven't used liquid eyeliner in a long time start with a lighter color and go from there.

Great!

5/5
It is a wonderful eye liner. Very smooth and stay all day. Thank you.

The Best!

5/5
I am a blonde with blonde eyelashes and eyebrows. I have used eyeliners for "bald-looking" eyes since I was a teen-ager. This is the first eyeliner that I truly love. It took a week or two of experimenting, but then I mastered the application. I put it on very lightly & immediately smudge with a smudger/brush duo. I have three shades, but generally use the amber which I didn't think I would like, but I have discovered that I can also use these color, applied very lightly and after having applied it as eyeliner, on my blonde eyebrows. So, if I need to re-apply after a work-out or swim, I can carry only one pencil to do two jobs! Thank you, Jane Iredale for this absolutely wonderful product!!! (I might add that I am very sensitive to many products, but have no problems with mystikol.

Mystikol

5/5
I have read the reviews on Mystikol and would like to defend it. I have purchased numerous malachite and aquamarine and love them. I had lasik surgery on one eye and have difficulty putting on liners. However, Mystikol makes it so easy and goes on so smooth that it looks like I took a long time in applying the liner but it was just one quick stroke. Recently, I purchased it and gave as gifts to friends and family who also love it. I have used JI for several years and think the mystikol is one of the best JI products aside from the mineral foundation.

Half Love?

3/5
I have purchased 3 colors and they all come out different. One barely has color that will come out and with both with both of the others, one end is overflowing! Love the color and texture! Just wish the consistency was there. I threw away the boxes so I cannot return to the spa where I purchased! Love everything else I have purchased!

Our Response

Hi there, It’s wonderful you’ve tried three different shades! We are happy to let you know that we’ve made improvements, and we have a much more consistent product now.

Could be improved

2/5
I have onyx, aquamarine and lapis lazuli mystikols. The onyx is a mess- clumps and product gets outside of tube. Onyx is hard to blend and creates too thick of a dark line. Lapis lazuli is better, the line smoother and thinner than onyx, but also messy to use. Aquamarine is the best. Thinnest line and doesn't seem to get all over outside of tube. I don't like the highlighter end. I use powder eyeshadow instead. Almost a great product-needs some improvements in container, applicator and better formulation of onyx shade.

Disappointed

1/5
Goes on thick and clumpy. Would not purchase again.

Our Response

Hi there, Mystikol should glide on smoothly, and perhaps yours is not working right. If you are interested in a replacement or an exchange, please contact a Personal Shopper at personalshoppers@janeiredale.com or 1-877-869-9420.

great

5/5
died and gone to heaven !...love it stays put and if it doesnt it becomes smoky and great i am testing to see how long it last...so far over a month now ...each day i just love this product!!

Mystikols are Musts

5/5
I'm one of those people who often feel very naked without eyeliner. I think I look alright without it, but after getting my first Mystikol, I feel like it truly makes my eyes stand out! I have Onyx, Citrine, Aquamarine, Amethyst, and Malachite. I just ordered the Topaz, and can't wait to try it! Anyway, I love these eyeliners because they go on very smooth. I've tried eyeliners from the drugstore and not liked them because it felt like I had to really press hard in order to get a decent depth of color, and that hurt! Mystikols go on smooth and stay on really well, even through a hot sweaty game of soccer! Plus I adore the highlighter; I put a little in the inner corners of my eyes to brighten them, and a little just under the arch of my brow to add a tiny bit of lift. So neat! My favorites are definitely the Aquamarine, Amethyst, and Onyx. Aquamarine is a beautiful color that looks great with my brown eyes and a similarly colored top. Amethyst adds the right amount of darkness but has that beautiful purple color in it, and Onyx is perfect for when I really want my eyes to pop! The only thing I don't like about it is that that one tends to push product all the way up to the end of the cap! When I close it, some oozes out and I do have to wipe it off every time I use it. :( Otherwise, no complains. The Malachite is a nice color too, though I'm not too crazy about the Citrine. I feel like I have to apply it numerous times before I'm satisfied with the color. Anyway, great product Jane! I won't ever go back to drugstore eyeliner!

Mystikol

5/5
I ordered the Aquamarine and love the color and the ease of application. I did not experince any 'clumping' issues whatsoever. Glides on smooth and the color lasts all day!! Love this product and will be ordering a few more colors!

Nice but not perfect.

3/5
I love the colors (I have Dark Topaz and Lapis Lazuli) and they are easy to apply when they cooperate but like other folks I have had clumping problems.

Terrible product

1/5
I had to return it. I couldn't control the pencil. Too dark; too unmanageable. It sounded great.

LOVE IT

4/5
I really like this eyeliner. It goes on smooth and silky. I am allergic to other purple eyeliners and this is the first one that I haven't been allergic to. However, I really don't use the highlighter end and would love to see this same eyeliner with a smudger on the other end. I have to use a smudger from another pencil I have to perform this task.

Love Mystikols

5/5
I have purchased the Topaz, Amethyst and Malachite and I love them all. I know some reviewers state difficulty in applying but I find that if you apply with a liner brush these eyeliners have all day staying power! The colors are rich and beautiful and I love how I can create different looks--soft or bold.

I LOVE The Citrine Color!

4/5
This is my first JI review even though every makeup item I own is JI. Ireceived this tonite and felt the need to defend it. I bought one of these when they first came out but it was the darker brown and it was too dark for me so I had to send it back but that was my only complaint so I jumped at buying the much lighter counterpart. This color is GREAT for my fair skin and makes my green eyes pop! I think it goes on soft and smooth. I am also very exited to be able to wear eyeliner again! The only reason I didn't give five stars is that I wish the highlighter was a bit darker. A cool idea I have seen working for Lancome years ago was the stylo and you could pick the colors on each end and buy only replacement cartridges for the side that is empty...I could see that making these a lot of fun!

LOVE The Bronze Color!

4/5
This is my first JI review even though every makeup item I own is JI. Ireceived this tonite and felt the need to defend it. I bought one of these when they first came out but it was the darker brown and it was too dark for me so I had to send it back but that was my only complaint so I jumped at buying the much lighter counterpart. This color is GREAT for my fair skin and makes my green eyes pop! I think it goes on soft and smooth. I am also very exited to be able to wear eyeliner again! The only reason I didn't give five stars is that I wish the highlighter was a bit darker. A cool idea I have seen working for Lancome years ago was the stylo and you could pick the colors on each end and buy only replacement cartridges for the side that is empty...I could see that making these a lot of fun!

Mystikol onyx

1/5
I truly love Jane Iredale products. However I hated the Mystikol Onyx. It was extremely hard to apply and smudged. I would not recommend this product.

Mystikol onyx

5/5
I truly love Jane Iredale products. However I hated the Mystikol Onyx. It was extremely hard to apply and smudged. I would not recommend this product.

Long lasting color

4/5
I have green eyes and I'm enjoying wearing the Citrine as an "everyday" color. It adds some definition without overwhelming my eyes. There's a bit of a learning curve in the application, but a good angled eyeliner brush helps smooth things out.

Mystikol

4/5
I don't usually write reviews but I had to respond to the ones that say this product goes on thick and clumpy. Couldn't disagree more. I recently ordered two (the brown and the aquamarine) and each one goes on smoothly and in a fine line. I like this product so much, I plan on ordering it in additional colors.

Mystikol

1/5
Completely agree that this product is a MESS, the dark side of my product was all over the outside of the tip and springy part and the cap was full, it ended up all over my hands. Don't recommend this, needs some tweaking to be a product worthy of the Jane Iredale name. Very disappointed.

Clumpy and hard to use

1/5
The applicator tip is very fat and impossible to use as an eye liner unless you want a very thick line. I have tried applying with a smaller eyeliner brush but still very messy.

Very nice!

5/5
I tried the Mystikol eyeliner for the first time last night. I did think it went on a little thick but it was so easy to smudge that I was able to achieve the look I wanted. I especially like the highlighter end for the inside of the eye. Nice product!

A bit expensive but Awesome!

5/5
It's hard to tell how much you get for $20 but it seems like not a lot. I'll have to see how long it lasts. As one of the reviews says it does go on a little clumpy on the bottom but blending takes care of that. No problems on the top lid. I have the dark topaz and the amethyst... I forgot how great the deep purple colors make my eyes look! Now I have to have the ripe plum mascara.

Our Response

Hi there, It may not look like a lot but we have tested it and with normal daytime use, this should last you about a year! If you are doing heavy smokey eyes, a bit less. We think that's a great value.

LA

5/5
For me, this truly is the best eye product out there. I LOVE the smoky eye effect, and because I can't draw a straight line, it becomes the best! The first time I applied one of the eyeliners, I fell in love with it! It's so easy to apply, but even more so, the colors just knock my socks off! I do believe I need ALL of them and will probably purchase the rest today. I really was never a make up kind of gal, but since I have been introduced to the Jane Iredale line, I can't seem to get enough of it!

Mystikol Eyeliner

1/5
Goes on thick and "clumpy" Certainly not as easy as directions make it look. Yucky. Will return the one I have and also the 2 I just ordered. Pretty colors, but thick.

Our Response

We are so sorry you are disappointed. It is possible you received a faulty product. We would be happy to replace it, if you would like. in the meantime, please try wiping any excess product off on the inside edge of the cap, or a tissue. Alternatively, you may use a brush to apply and blend.

Blog

Easy Daytime Eye Makeup - Three Looks Featuring Mystikols

Learn how to create fun and lasting eye looks featuring Mystikols. ...[MORE]

Press

  • OKMagazine.com
    Fall 2013

  • Lucky
    May 2013

We ship to

I see my country and I'd like to

I'd like to visit a US location

Information about jane iredale in countries not listed above →